Judgment Time

This worksheet helps students in Grades 5, 6, and 7 strengthen argument writing, critical thinking, and perspective-taking skills by responding to an opinion excerpt about banning homework. Students evaluate the author’s claim, decide whether they agree or disagree, and write a clear judgment supported by reasons and examples, encouraging independent thinking and thoughtful evaluation of persuasive texts.

Learning Goals

• Argument Writing (Grades 5-7)
  State a clear opinion and support it with logical reasons and relevant examples.
• Evaluating Author Claims
  Analyze the strength and fairness of an opinion-based argument.
• Evidence & Reasoning
  Use personal experience, observation, or research to support a position.
• Perspective-Taking
  Consider how someone with an opposing viewpoint might defend a different stance.

Instructional Benefits

• Teacher-Created Resource
  Designed by educators to align with upper elementary and middle school ELA standards.
• Structured Writing Prompts
  Guides students step by step from judgment to justification.
• Critical Reflection Focus
  Encourages learners to question ideas rather than accept opinions at face value.
• Flexible Classroom Use
  Ideal for independent writing, discussion, debate prep, or assessment.
• Low-Prep Format
  Print-and-go worksheet for classroom or homeschool instruction.

This printable worksheet builds confidence in opinion writing, critical evaluation, and reasoning with evidence. By forming and defending their own judgments while considering opposing views, students develop stronger argument skills and independent thinking habits. It’s a practical, engaging resource for both classroom instruction and homeschool learning.

This worksheet is part of our critical comprehension worksheets collection.