Source Strength Test

In this worksheet, students evaluate the credibility of a source excerpt by analyzing four categories: author expertise, date, publisher, and evidence. They use a checklist to determine whether each category is strong, weak, or unclear based on information provided in the text. Students then write a brief explanation for each rating to show their reasoning. After evaluating all categories, they give an overall judgment of the source’s credibility. This activity teaches students how to break down a source into measurable components rather than making quick assumptions. By examining key credibility indicators, learners develop the analytical habits needed for academic research and digital literacy. The structured grid format helps them practice organized thinking and supported evaluation.

Curriculum Matched Skills

English Language Arts – Evaluating Source Credibility

English Language Arts – Research Skills and Source Analysis

English Language Arts – Identifying Author Expertise and Evidence Quality

English Language Arts – Critical Reading and Analytical Reasoning

This worksheet is part of our credibility of sources worksheets collection.