The Bluebird Painting

Students read two mini-stories-one written correctly using by and with, and the other containing incorrect usage. They must determine which version makes logical sense and explain why in one or two sentences. This activity strengthens understanding of how by identifies the agent and with identifies the instrument, especially within descriptive writing. It also enhances reading comprehension by requiring students to detect subtle grammatical errors that affect meaning.

Curriculum Matched Skills

English Language Arts – Evaluating Correct vs. Incorrect Grammar

English Language Arts – Preposition Use in Narrative Contexts

English Language Arts – Analytical Reading Skills

English Language Arts – Justifying a Choice with Written Explanation

This worksheet is part of our by vs. with worksheets collection.