Debate Divide Answer Key

This worksheet presents two excerpts showing contrasting Reconstruction views: one from the Radical Republicans and one from President Andrew Johnson. Students read both perspectives and answer questions comparing their beliefs about how the nation should rebuild. The questions require students to identify differences in goals, evaluate which viewpoint protects freedmen’s rights, and reflect on how disagreements slowed progress. The worksheet helps students see that Reconstruction was shaped by major political conflict.

By examining two opposing viewpoints, students strengthen their compare-and-contrast reading skills. The worksheet reinforces close reading by requiring students to interpret primary-source excerpts and draw evidence-based conclusions. It also supports critical thinking, as students must evaluate which policy approach better protected people’s rights. Engaging with historical arguments encourages deeper understanding of how conflicting perspectives shape national decisions.